Review – URTH Square Filter Holders
It’s been almost 18 months since Gobe (now rebranded to URTH) released their range of Square ND Filters. In fact, we tested them while we were in Fiji in February 2020 which was our last time overseas before being imprisoned Down Under due to Covid-19.
So, we were excited when they finally launched their Square Filter Holder along with many new products in July 2021. In particular, we wanted to test the 100mm Square Filter Holder as we wanted to see how the rubber built-in gasket worked. We’ve never seen a holder that has the gasket built into the holder. Other brands usually attach these to the back of the ND Filter, and in the past, we’ve had to attach a NiSi Filters gasket to the back of some Gobe/Urth ND Filters to avoid light leaks when taking long exposures.
In this review, we’ll also compare it to the NiSi Square Filter Holder, however, please keep in mind that we still have the original V5 NiSi Square Filter Holder.
Urth, as usual, was kind enough to send us the 100mm Square Filter Holder for this review. Although we received the filter free of charge, this post is an unbiased review. Please read our disclaimer at the bottom of this post.
What is a Square Filter Holder?
In a nutshell, a Square Filter Holder is a product that is designed to be attached to the front of a lens by the way of an adapter ring to mount a Square Filter (although the only real square filters are the ND Filters). Filter Holders can usually hold at least two square filters and a C-PL filter at the same time. Due to their design, they rarely cause vignetting in an image even when three filters are combined. A standard 100mm Square Filter Holder that holds 100x100mm and 100x150mm filters will be suitable for most lenses, however, some ultra-wide-angle lenses will require a customised Square Filter Holder to accommodate the extreme angle of view and will require larger filters. Most Square Filter Holders will also allow you to insert a C-PL (Circular Polarizer) Filter and rotate independently from the Square Filters. For smaller mirrorless systems you may also want to consider a 75mm Square Filter Holder that can accommodate the same amount of filters but the filters are smaller and cheaper.
Quite frankly, a Filter Holder is really nothing more than an accessory that allows you to stack filters on the front of a lens. As long as it is well-made and is easy to attach to the lens, all Filter Holders, no matter what brand, are created equal. Some may have a few bells and whistles such as a way to lock the filters in place or maybe a different method of inserting the filter, or even a built-in gasket. Regardless, the most important factor is to make sure you place good quality filters in the holder.
Above: The URTH 100mm Square Filter Holder
Why use a Filter Holder?
Square Filter Holders are a standard item in practically every serious landscape photographer’s bag, however, if you only use ND Filters to take long exposure images, or if you only use ND Grads to balance the exposure, then you do not need to use a Filter Holder. In this case, you are better off buying a Circular ND or Circular ND Grad filter. However, if your goal is to combine ND Filters with an ND Grad Filter, and maybe even a C-PL filter at the same time, then using a Square Filter Holder and filters is really the obvious choice. Although you can stack Circular Filters at a pinch, it is not ideal and certainly not advised on ultra-wide-angle lenses due to excessive vignetting.
A Square Filter Holder will also give you a lot more flexibility with your composition when taking a shot with an ND Grad Filter. Because you can adjust the filter in the holder, it allows you to properly align the filter with the horizon or brightest area of the composition without adjusting the camera’s position. A Circular ND Grad Filter mounted on a lens is not adjustable and will require you to position the camera so that the filter is in the optimum position for the brightest area of the scene, which may not be necessarily the composition that you want.
It also depends on the type of photography that you are interested in. As travel photographers, although, we do use our Square Filter System for tripod-mounted shots, we will mostly use the less cumbersome option of Circular Filters for handheld shots.
When would you use a Square Filter Holder?
As mentioned above, a Square Filter Holder and filters are almost exclusively used in Landscape Photography, or at any time when taking tripod-mounted shots that require multiple filters to be stacked. If you want to avoid any vignetting in your shots when stacking filters then a Square Filter Holder is the solution.
The URTH 100mm Square Filter Holder
The URTH Square Filter Holder was only released in mid-2021, so it is a bit of a latecomer to a very competitive market. Having said that, Urth were using their very successful circular filter business as a launchpad into the Square Filter market. It really was only a matter of time before they progressed in this direction.
The filter holder arrived in a robust mid-grey re-cyclable box. All products that are URTH branded are now packaged with the same mid-grey colour. Do not throw away the box straight away as your unique code is printed on the underside of the box lid. At your convenience, take a few moments to register your product to plant 5 trees in deforested regions of the world.
Upon opening the box the Square Filter Holder will be securely held in place by square black recyclable packaging.
The filter holder itself is constructed with Magnalium, which is an aluminium alloy comprising 5% magnesium and 95% aluminium making it much stronger. The filter holder is convex-shaped and sleeker looking than the current NiSi Filter Holder which is octagonally shaped (NiSi V6 Holder). You will also notice that there are no protruding locking knobs on the side of the holder with the exception of low-profile dials on both sides that control the rotation of the C-PL (Circular Polarizer) if it is being used.
In comparison to our NiSi Square Filter Holder V5 (sorry, can’t compare it to the V6 holder) is slightly wider but smaller in height.
Above: Inside the box – the 100mm Square Filter Holder and 86mm lens adapter
The filter holder has the ability to accommodate a Circular C-PL Filter, and two 100mm Square Filters simultaneously (sold separately). Alternatively, if you have the 75mm Filter Holder it will hold a C-PL and two 75mm Square Filters. This is one slot less than the NiSi holder but then most people would rarely use 3 slots anyway. If you commonly use 3 square filters simultaneously then the Urth Filter Holder will not suit your needs.
Due to the fact that URTH ND Filters are not provided with an attached rubber gasket to eliminate light leaks, the filter holder has a built-in rubber gasket on the edge of the inner rim. Although this added feature is not required if only using an ND Graduated Filter, it is essential when using ND Filters that allow you to obtain lengthy exposure times. We had the issue of light leaks when using the GOBE Square ND10000 13-stop filter but a spare NiSi rubber gasket applied to the back of the filter fixed it immediately. Our only concern at this stage is whether the rubber gasket will remain in place over time with continual use. Only time will tell, although URTH does offer a Lifetime Warranty on the product.
The Filter Holder also has a lock on the back of the holder. This locks the adapter ring once attached to the holder. The holder also includes the standard 86mm adapter ring. When ordering the Filter Holder make sure that you order the appropriate adapter rings (sold separately) to fit all lenses that you will be using with the Filter Holder.
Lastly, as mentioned previously, there are two low-profile geared wheels on the left and right sides of the holder that operate the rotation of the C-PL if attached.
We tested the filter holder on a Full Frame sensor camera with our Laowa 15mm f/2 Zero-Distortion lens and could find no vignetting, however, once filters were added there was some darkening in the corners although no more than our NiSi V5 Square Filter Holder.
Attaching the Square Filter Holder
Everyone will have their own method of attaching the filter holder but for us, we have found below is the easiest way.
- Always remove any circular filters attached to your lens
- Attach the appropriate size adapter ring to the front of your lens
- If you are using the C-PL filter (sold separately), then remove the supplied 86mm Adapter Ring from the Filter Holder. The C-PL filter is 86mm and therefore will attach to the adapter rings (sold separately) as well as hold the Filter Holder. If you are not using the C-PL filter, then remove the 86mm adapter ring from the Filter Holder and attach it to the adapter ring that you attached to the lens in Step 2.
- To attach the Filter Holder to the adapter ring we have found that the best way is to locate the two small metal tabs on the inner rim of the holder and insert the adapter ring under these tabs first. Then secure with the locking knob which is located on the opposite corner of the filter holder. Slightly loosen the locking knob if the adapter ring does not drop into place. DO NOT CONTINUALLY TURN THE LOCKING KNOB ANTI-CLOCKWISE AS IT WILL DETACH FROM THE HOLDER and you may lose it. If you lose it you will not be able to hold the Filter Holder in place. TIP: we used a small flat head screwdriver to tighten the locking knob screw. Ideally, this locking knob should not be able to be removed.
- Once locked in place, check to make sure it is securely connected before inserting the filters. Initially, we have found that the filters are quite tight in the filter holder. This may loosen over time with some use. We would suggest, that you hold the camera securely when adding the filters or consider adding the filters prior to attaching the filter holder to the camera.
- To remove the Filter Holder slightly turn the Locking Knob anti-clockwise to release.
Above: Sony 16-35 f/4 lens without any attachments
Above: Sony 16-35 f/4 lens – attaching the 72mm adapter ring
Above: Sony 16-35 f/4 lens – attaching the 86mm adapter ring to the 72mm adapter ring
Above: Sony 16-35 f/4 lens – attaching the filter holder to the 86mm adapter ring
Above: Sony 16-35 f/4 lens with a Graduated ND Filter
Above: Sony 16-35 f/4 lens with an ND Filter in the first slot
Please Note: The Filter Holder has a built-in rubber gasket to prevent light leaks when using ND filters for long exposures. If you are using another brand of ND Filter that already has a gasket applied to the rear of the filter, you may have to remove this if the filter is too tight in the first slot. As a result of the built-in rubber gasket, it is extremely tight when inserting a Graduated ND Filter into the first slot due to the friction. If you are only using a Graduated ND Filter then you may want to consider using the filter in the second slot.
The URTH 100mm Filter Holder is a great addition to their product range, however, in our opinion, it still needs a few tweaks to be perfect. Firstly, the locking knob on the rear of the holder is not ideal and could easily be lost. We also think that it should be a different colour to the holder as it is quite difficult to see. The only other minor improvement is the tightness of the filters in the slots although, as mentioned, this may improve with use. The holder has been designed primarily to be used with URTH/Gobe ND Filters as they do not have a rubber gasket attached to the rear of the filter and therefore are easier to insert into the first slot. However, if you own existing Square ND Filters from another manufacturer that has a gasket attached to the rear of the filter you will more than likely have to remove the gasket to use in the first slot of the URTH holder.
All-in-all, it is a sleek, functional and well-designed holder that has been a long time coming and we’re sure that photographers will get a lifetime of use out of the product. We envisage that this product would be perfect for the photographer that is aiming to purchase their first filter holder.
Except for the purchase of the individual filters, here’s what you’ll need to order if you want to use the URTH 100mm Filter Holder –
- URTH 100mm or 75mm Filter Holder
- URTH Adapter Rings if using lenses with a smaller thread than 86mm
- URTH C-PL Filter (optional)
The adapter rings are available from 37mm – 86mm for the 100mm Filter Holder and 37mm – 67mm for the 75mm Filter Holder.
This filter holder is RECOMMENDED
Other Gobe/URTH Filter Reviews
If you are interested in reading any of our other Gobe Filter reviews click the links below –
Review – GOBE ND2-400 Variable Filter + Discount Code
First Impressions: GOBE Filters + Discount Code
First Impressions: URTH Filters + Discount Code
URTH FILTER KITS + Discount Code
Review – GOBE 100mm Square ND Filter + Discount Code
Disclaimer: Although we are affiliated with URTH Filters and receive a commission on any sales when using the coupon code, this review is totally unbiased (we are also NiSi Resellers). As Professional Photographers we would never recommend the use of any product unless we use the product ourselves. We did receive the filter with compliments of URTH Filters but were not paid for this review. We may also receive commissions on other links in this post, however, we try our best to keep things fair and balanced, in order to help you make the best choice.